Colts vs. Chiefs Prediction, Odds & Picks for Sept. 20: Chiefs Grind Out Win
It’s the primetime clash of week 2 of the NFL slate between AFC rivals as the Indianapolis Colts take on the Kansas City Chiefs Sunday night, and we have you covered with our Colts vs. Chiefs prediction. Indianapolis took a 41-23 home beating at the hands of the Baltimore Ravens in their opener last Sunday. The Colts failed to cover the line as a 2.5-point underdog. Kansas City crushed Denver 31-10 at home in their opener Monday night. The Chiefs covered the line as a 2.5-point favorite in that game.
In the all-time regular season series between the teams, the Colts own a 14-10 advantage. However, it was Kansas City that picked up a 23-20 overtime road win in the most recent matchup on November 23, 2025. Read on to get our Colts vs. Chiefs prediction.
Indianapolis Colts Trying to Even Record
The Colts started strong against Baltimore but fell apart quickly. Indianapolis never regrouped from that point and went down in defeat as they were diced up defensively. Indianapolis took a 6-0 lead as they scored on their opening drive. The Colts then gave up 28 unanswered points, trailing 28-6, and never got closer than 15 the rest of the way.
Indianapolis was destroyed 506-251 in total offense in the game. In addition, the Colts gave up 23 first downs while recording 17 and lost time of possession by a 35:20 to 24:40 margin. The Colts also turned the ball over twice while recording just one takeaway in the game.
Indianapolis Colts Summary
Indianapolis enters week 2 ranked 28th in the league in passing offense, averaging 149 yards per game through the air. The Colts are 21st in the league in rushing offense by averaging 102 yards per contest on the ground. Indianapolis is tied for 18th in scoring offense at 23 points per game. The Colts rank 31st in the league in scoring defense, allowing 41 points per contest.
Daniel Jones completed 19 of 31 passes for 166 yards with one touchdown and one interception. He added four yards on the ground while getting sacked twice. Jonathan Taylor is the feature back for the Colts’ offense. He finished with 19 carries for 98 yards and two scores. No other Indianapolis running back had a carry in the game.
Keenan Allen led Indianapolis with six receptions for 32 yards in the contest. Alec Pierce added four catches for 61 yards. Taylor (23 yards) and tight end Tyler Warren (13 yards, TD) each had three receptions, while Josh Downs added two receptions for 37 yards. Spencer Shrader hit two of three extra point attempts and connected on his lone field goal attempt, which came from 58 yards.
Get Up to $1,000 Matched in FanCash Bet $20, Get $350 FanCash Kansas City Chiefs Seek to Roll Behind Mahomes
The Chiefs shrugged off the disappointment of their 6-11 campaign last season by opening the 2026 campaign by thumping Denver. Kansas City improved to 1-0 on the year and looks to win two straight to start the year. Kansas City was even after one quarter but took a 14-7 lead at the half. The Chiefs pushed the margin to 21-7 early in the third quarter and didn’t let Denver closer than 11 from there.
In the game, Kansas City rolled up a 392-176 advantage in total offense. The Chiefs picked up 19 first downs while allowing nine and had a 33:42 to 26:18 time-of-possession margin. In addition, the Chiefs had two takeaways while committing one giveaway in the win.
Kansas City Chiefs Summary
Kansas City enters week 2 ranked 23rd in the league in passing offense, averaging 172 yards per game through the air. The Chiefs are 2nd in the league in rushing offense by averaging 220 yards per contest on the ground. Kansas City is tied for 8th in scoring offense, averaging 31 points per game. The Chiefs are tied for 2nd in the league in scoring defense, allowing 10 points per contest.
Patrick Mahomes completed 15 of 27 passes for 184 yards with two touchdowns and one interception. He finished with 23 rushing yards plus a score while getting sacked twice. Kenneth Walker III had a big debut with the Chiefs. He ran 23 times for 173 yards and a score. Rookie Emmitt Johnson (eight carries, 24 yards) is the second back in the system.
In the passing game, Travis Kelce (71 yards), Walker III (18 yards, TD) and Xavier Worthy (18 yards) each had three catches to lead the team. Johnson (44 yards) and Rashee Rice (19 yards, TD) both added two catches for the Chiefs in the contest. Harrison Butker connected on all four extra point attempts and hit his lone field goal attempt, which came from 28 yards.
Colts vs. Chiefs Predictions
Kansas City Chiefs -6 (Fanatics, -110)
There simply was nothing redeeming about the Indianapolis defense in their opener. The Colts were sliced, diced, pureed, and julienned by the Ravens.
While Kansas City isn’t as explosive offensively as Baltimore, they have Walker III, who provides a dimension the Chiefs have lacked in recent years.
The Colts were pedestrian offensively, and until we see the defense improve, you can’t like them, especially on the road. Arrowhead is a tough enough place to play, but when you get torched at home, you have to fade the Colts accordingly.
Best Bet: Give the six at Fanatics and take the Chiefs here.
Under 46 (Fanatics, -110)
Indianapolis went Over the total in their season opener, combining with Baltimore for 64 points. The Colts went Over the number in three of their last four games dating back to the end of last season.
Kansas City stayed Under in their Week 1 win. That marked the ninth time in the last 10 games that the Chiefs hit the Under dating back to last season. In addition, eight of the last 10 meetings between these teams fell short of the mark.
With Kansas City not being overly explosive, this could be a grind-it-out contest that keeps the game under the number.
Best Bet: Head over to Fanatics and take the Under here.
Get Up to $1,000 Matched in FanCash Bet $20, Get $350 FanCash -
NFL Trade Deadline: The Completed Blockbusters and Potential Future Movers
-
Trade $25 Get $55 on Celtics vs Bucks NBA: Use Kalshi Code PREMARLINES
-
NBA Prediction Markets for Nov. 6: Back Title Contenders in NBA Cup
-
Trade $25 Get $55 on Nets vs Mavericks NBA: Use Kalshi Code PREMARLINES
-
Vikings' Kyler Murray Out Week-to-Week With Strained Hamstring
-
New York Sportsbooks Are Hammered Despite $658M Weekly Handle