2026 Heisman Trophy Race After Week 11: Favorites, Odds & Top Contenders

The 2026 Heisman Trophy race tightened considerably after Week 11, with several top contenders putting up strong performances as the regular season enters its final stretch. Jeremiah Smith moved back to the top of the betting market, while Darian Mensah, Devon Dampier, and C.J. Carr remain firmly in contention.
At this point in the season, team success, individual production, and signature performances all matter. Smith is chasing history at wide receiver, Mensah has been one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the country, Dampier continues to lead an undefeated Utah team, and Carr owns one of the biggest wins of the season.
Below, we’ll break down the top Heisman Trophy favorites, current DraftKings odds, season statistics, and what each player still needs to do to win the award.
How Week 11 Changed the Heisman Trophy Race
Week 11 created another shift at the top of the Heisman board. Jeremiah Smith strengthened his case with 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown, while Darian Mensah responded to Miami’s loss to Notre Dame with 382 passing yards and a touchdown against Duke.
Devon Dampier also continued his rise, producing four total touchdowns while keeping Utah undefeated. C.J. Carr stayed in the race after another efficient win, but his quieter Week 11 performance let the other contenders gain ground.
The result is a tighter group entering the final weeks, with Smith leading the market and Mensah, Dampier, and Carr still close enough to make a late push.
Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State (-144)
Smith enters the final stretch as the favorite in the 2026 Heisman Trophy odds, and his Week 11 performance only strengthened that position. The Ohio State star finished with 11 receptions for 117 yards and a touchdown against Northwestern, giving him six 100-yard games this season.
Smith has also scored in seven consecutive games, continuing a season in which he’s rewritten both Ohio State and Big Ten receiving records. His combination of volume, explosiveness, and consistency has separated him from the other non-quarterbacks in the race.
The biggest obstacle to Smith’s Heisman case is Ohio State’s three losses. Quarterbacks leading College Football Playoff contenders traditionally have an advantage, and Smith will need voters to separate his individual production from the Buckeyes’ overall record.
Still, Smith has already made history, and he has a chance to do more as the season progresses. If he closes the season with another few dominant performances, his statistical resume may be strong enough to overcome Ohio State’s team struggles and make him the first wide receiver to win the Heisman since DeVonta Smith.
Darian Mensah, QB, Miami (+340)
Mensah remains one of the strongest challengers to Jeremiah Smith in the 2026 Heisman Trophy race. Miami’s loss to Notre Dame hurt his momentum, but Mensah responded with 382 passing yards and a touchdown against Duke in Week 11 to keep himself firmly in contention.
His season-long efficiency is what separates him from most of the quarterback field. Mensah has thrown for more than 3,000 yards and 29 touchdowns with only two interceptions, while completing over 76% of his passes. That combination of volume and mistake-free football gives him one of the cleanest statistical profiles in the country.
The biggest issue is that Mensah doesn’t currently have the same signature win as C.J. Carr, while Devon Dampier has the advantage of leading an undefeated team. Still, Miami remains in the College Football Playoff picture, and Mensah has enough high-profile games left to strengthen his case.
If Miami keeps winning and Mensah maintains this level of efficiency, he should remain one of the top Heisman Trophy favorites through the end of the regular season.
Devon Dampier, QB, Utah (+700)
Dampier has become one of the biggest risers in the 2026 Heisman Trophy race, and his case is built around both production and team success. Utah remains undefeated, giving Dampier something none of the other leading contenders can match right now.
He added another strong performance in Week 11, throwing for 204 yards and two touchdowns while rushing for 100 yards and two more scores against Arizona. That gave him back-to-back four-touchdown games after another huge performance against BYU.
Dampier’s dual-threat ability is what makes his Heisman case intriguing. He has produced more than 2,200 passing yards and 22 touchdowns through the air, while adding over 500 rushing yards and nine scores on the ground.
If Utah stays unbeaten, Dampier’s candidacy should continue to gain momentum. A perfect regular season and Big 12 title would give him one of the strongest team resumes in the field, and his rushing production gives him a path to separate himself from the other quarterbacks in the race.
C.J. Carr, QB, Notre Dame (+940)
Carr remains firmly in the 2026 Heisman Trophy race, even after a quieter Week 11 performance. His biggest advantage is still the signature win over Miami, where he threw for 319 yards and three touchdowns without a turnover.
Carr followed that with 217 passing yards and two touchdowns against Boston College. It wasn’t the kind of performance that would move him to the top of the Heisman board, but Notre Dame still won comfortably and remained firmly in the College Football Playoff picture.
His case is built around efficiency, team success, and one of the best individual wins among the leading contenders. The issue is that Jeremiah Smith, Darian Mensah, and Devon Dampier all produced more eye-catching Week 11 performances.
Carr likely needs another major statistical outing down the stretch to regain momentum. If Notre Dame keeps winning and he adds another signature performance, he still has a realistic path to the award.
Best Heisman Trophy Long Shots
The top of the 2026 Heisman Trophy race has separated itself, but several quarterbacks still have an outside chance to make a late push. Gunner Stockton, Keelon Russell, Gio Lopez, and Drew Mestemaker all sit well behind the favorites in the betting market, but each has a case worth watching over the final weeks.
Gunner Stockton, QB, Georgia (+2500)
Stockton has the strongest team resume among the long shots. Georgia is 9-1 and ranked No. 1, while Stockton has thrown for 2,109 yards and 21 touchdowns this season. He also added five total touchdowns against Ole Miss before accounting for two more in a 48-21 win over Missouri.
His biggest issue is volume. Stockton’s numbers don’t match the top four contenders, but leading the No. 1 team in the country gives him a path if Georgia keeps winning and he produces a signature performance down the stretch.
Keelon Russell, QB, Alabama (+5000)
Russell remains a long shot, but Alabama’s 8-2 record keeps him relevant. He threw for three touchdowns in the win over LSU and helped the Crimson Tide follow that with a 21-6 victory over Vanderbilt.
Russell likely needs a huge finish, including a standout performance against Auburn, but quarterbacks leading playoff contenders are always difficult to completely dismiss.
Gio Lopez, QB, Wake Forest (+5000)
Lopez has quietly built one of the better dual-threat resumes in the country. Through Week 11, he had 2,377 passing yards, 19 passing touchdowns, 351 rushing yards, and eight rushing scores. He helped Wake Forest crush SMU 49-7 with 201 passing yards, one passing touchdown, and two rushing scores.
Wake Forest’s 9-1 record gives Lopez an interesting late-season narrative if the Demon Deacons remain in the ACC and CFP races.
Drew Mestemaker, QB, Oklahoma State (+12500)
Mestemaker has the best raw passing production of the long shots. He leads the FBS with 3,239 passing yards and 30 touchdowns, keeping him in the conversation despite Oklahoma State’s losses.
The team record is the biggest obstacle. Mestemaker would likely need massive numbers over the final weeks, along with several favorites stumbling, to make a serious move.
What Will Decide the 2026 Heisman Trophy?
The final weeks will likely come down to a combination of individual production, team success, and signature moments.
Jeremiah Smith owns the best statistical case, but Ohio State’s losses could hurt him. Devon Dampier has the advantage of leading an undefeated Utah team, while Darian Mensah and C.J. Carr remain quarterbacks for major playoff contenders.
One huge late-season performance could still swing the race. Conference championship opportunities, rivalry games, and how each candidate performs under pressure will matter just as much as season-long totals when voters make their final decisions.
Final Thoughts: Who Is the Heisman Favorite After Week 11?
Jeremiah Smith remains the clear betting favorite, but the race is far from finished. Mensah has the strongest passing resume among the quarterbacks, Dampier combines elite dual-threat production with an undefeated record, and Carr still owns one of the season’s best signature wins.
The next few weeks should determine whether Smith can hold off the quarterbacks or whether one late surge changes the 2026 Heisman Trophy odds again.