NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Picks for Nov. 17: Hagel, Draisaitl and More

Author Jason Green | Published at November 17, 2026
Best NHL Player Props & Anytime Goal Scorer Picks for tonight. We have some great value bets for props and anytime goal scorers.
Nov 3, 2026; Toronto, Ontario, CAN; Toronto Maple Leafs forward Auston Matthews (34) plays the puck against the Utah Mammoth zone in the third period at Scotiabank Arena. Mandatory Credit: Dan Hamilton-Imagn Images

Tuesday brings a full slate of NHL games, and that is great news for bettors, with many markets available for each game.

Let’s get right into it with the best player props and NHL anytime goal scorer picks for Nov. 17.

NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Picks Today (Nov. 17)

Anytime Goal Scorer #1: Brandon Hagel (+150) 

Good plus-money value here with Hagel, who ranks tied for sixth in the NHL in goals. Not only has he scored five goals over the last four games, but his Tampa Bay Lightning club will face a Washington Capitals team that has allowed 12 goals in the last two games.

Best Bet: Brandon Hagel anytime goal scorer – +150, Betway

You can pad your NHL betting bankroll with great sportsbook bonuses and the best sportsbooks in Canada.

Anytime Goal Scorer #2: Leon Draisaitl (+105) 

Another plus-money value bet on Draisaitl to score, as he leads the NHL in goals and has lit the lamp six times over the last five games. (If you want good odds but are willing to take a bigger risk, consider him as the first goal scorer in the game at +700, which he did in the last game.)

Best Bet: Leon Draisaitis anytime goal scorer – +105, Betway

Anytime Goal Scorer #3: Cutter Gauthier (+125) 

Once again, we find a good plus-money value bet on Gauthier scoring. He ranks second in the NHL in goals and has been on fire lately, with at least one goal in nine straight games. Tonight, his Anaheim Ducks squad takes on the St. Louis Blues, who gave up four goals in their last game and have conceded at least three goals in four of their last six games.

Best Bet: Cutter Gauthier anytime goal scorer – +125, Betway

There is no shortage of great Canadian live betting sites to bet on the action on the ice as it happens.

Anytime Goal Scorer #4: Auston Matthews or William Nylander 

Both of these Toronto Maple Leafs players are at +120 to score a goal tonight. While Matthews has only one goal in the last five games, he ranks tied for seventh in goals scored. Nylander has not lit the lamp in the last five games but has 11 goals this season. Both players have good value not because of their recent form, but because of who they will face tonight.

The Maple Leafs take on a Chicago Blackhawks team that ranks second-to-last in the league in GAA. The Blackhawks are reeling, having lost seven of their last eight games; in those seven losses, they allowed an average of 5.3 goals per game.

Best Bet: Auston Matthews or William Nylander anytime goal scorer – +120, Bet365

More NHL Player Props for Today's Slate of Games

Player Prop #1: Nikita Kucherov 2+ points (+115) 

Kucherov’s Tampa Bay Lightning take on the Washington Capitals tonight, and he offers good plus-money value to hit 2+ points. He ranks tied for 10th in the NHL with 28 points and has been playing well lately, with nine points over his last five games. On top of that, he will be facing a Caps team that has allowed 12 goals in its last two games. He notched one point in an early-season win over Washington and will get 2+ points tonight, which he has done five times in the last seven games.

Best Bet: Nikita Kucherov 2+ points – +115, Bet365 

Check out our prop betting guide for all the info for that bet type.

Player Prop #2: Connor McDavid 2+ points (-105) 

How can you not go with McDavid for 2+ points, as he leads the NHL in points by a wide margin? He recently tied the Great One, Wayne Gretzky, for the fastest to 40 assists in a season, and in 22 games this season, he has multiple points in 14 of them.

Best Bet: Connor McDavid 2+ points – -105, Bet365 

Player Prop #3: Kirill Kaprizov 1+ assists (-135) 

Kirill Kaprizov ranks third in the NHL in points and has 20 assists this season, which ranks 12th in the league. He is a solid bet to notch an assist tonight, with five assists in his last two games and 10 in seven games this month. His Minnesota Wild will be facing a Nashville Predators team that ranks seventh in the league in GAA, but in the opening game of the season, he had an assist. (If you want to be riskier for much better odds, you can take him at 2+ assists at +350).

Best Bet: Kirill Kaprizov 1+ assists – -135, Bet365 

The best NHL betting sites will have many prop bets for every NHL game.

Player Prop #4: Jack Eichel 4+ shots on goal (+140) 

Here is another solid value bet with plus-money odds on Eichel to have 4+ shots on goal. He leads the Golden Knights in points and shots on goal and ranks tied for second with nine goals. He has been pestering opposing goalies lately, with at least four shots in five of his last six games, including the last two, where he has totaled 11 shots. (You can also take the safer route and bet on 3+ shots at -170).

Best Bet: Jack Eichel 4+ shots on goal – +140, Bet365